Privacy / Regulation

State attorneys general could shore up EU-US Data Privacy Framework after Trump v. Slaughter

Hogan Lovells lawyers argue that selected state attorneys general, who are outside presidential control, could act as supplemental enforcers if the Commission wants extra assurances on FTC independence.

OpinionOpinion: the author's own view, summarised by us. It is not a news report or official guidance. By Bret Cohen and Julian Flamant, lawyers at Hogan Lovells, writing for the IAPP.

OpinionEU / USNotablePublishedOfficial source
Recital 60: DPF adequacy text that relied on the FTC removal protection struck down in Slaughter

In a contributed IAPP opinion piece, Hogan Lovells lawyers Bret Cohen and Julian Flamant respond to the US Supreme Court’s ruling in Trump v. Slaughter of 29 June 2026, which overruled Humphrey’s Executor and held that FTC commissioners are subject to the president’s power of removal. Recital 60 of the Commission’s 2023 DPF adequacy decision relied on that limit, which allowed removal only for inefficiency, neglect of duty or malfeasance.

On 31 July the EDPB asked the Commission to assess whether the judgment affects the adequacy decision. They add that Max Schrems has urged the Commission to “orderly withdraw” from the framework. Their own view is that the FTC keeps its enforcement powers.

If further safeguards are needed, they propose that a limited group of qualified state attorneys general serve as supplemental enforcers. These offices would draw on state consumer protection laws and could be named by organisations when they self-certify. The authors acknowledge open questions on differing powers, jurisdiction over EU complaints and coordination between offices.

Editor’s note: This article summarises a contributed opinion piece. The ruling’s date and holding and the EDPB request are checked against the EDPB’s letter; the proposal on state attorneys general is the authors’ own.

Why it matters

The adequacy decision makes FTC or Department of Transportation jurisdiction a condition of DPF certification and lets transfers to certified organisations proceed without further authorisation, so any Commission review prompted by Slaughter goes to the legal basis of transfers that rely on the DPF. Privacy teams should list which US transfers depend solely on the DPF and confirm that fallback mechanisms, such as standard contractual clauses, are ready. Teams should also record which enforcement body each US recipient named in its certification, because a supplemental state-level model could change that.

Status: Published. Contributed opinion; no Commission decision on the DPF has been reported

Sources

  1. Letter from EDPB Chair Anu Talus to Commissioner McGrath on the US Supreme Court judgment in Trump v. Slaughter, 31 July 2026 — European Data Protection Board
  2. Commission Implementing Decision (EU) 2023/1795 on the adequate level of protection of personal data under the EU-US Data Privacy Framework — EUR-LexPrimary source
  3. Could state attorneys general strengthen the DPF after Slaughter? — IAPP

Was this useful?

Prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the editor before publication. Spotted an error? Tell us — see our editorial policy and methodology.

Governance areas

Who should care

  • DPO
  • Legal & compliance
  • Procurement and vendor risk teams

Related

Latest

All news

Contact the editor

Tips, corrections, questions?

Write to The Steward, the editor of Data Governance Signal. Every message is read.

editor@datagovernancesignal.com