Privacy / Regulation

CJEU Advocate General says Facebook cannot be called 'free' when users pay with their personal data

Advocate General Medina proposes that handing over personal data and consenting to its commercial use counts as payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive, applied alongside the GDPR.

RegulationEUNotableNon-binding opinionOfficial source
C-643/25: AG opinion: personal data for commercial use can be payment under EU consumer law

Advocate General Laila Medina has advised the Court of Justice that disclosing personal data and consenting to its commercial use is a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive. The case, C-643/25, concerns the statement ‘Facebook is and remains free’ shown on Meta’s registration page in 2015, challenged by the German consumer federation Verbraucherzentrale Bundesverband. German lower courts had limited ‘free’ claims to financial costs; the Bundesgerichtshof referred the question.

In her view, a service cannot be labelled ‘free’ where data is required for commercial use, unless it is processed only to deliver the service or meet legal obligations. She rejected Meta’s argument that the GDPR displaces consumer law, saying both apply cumulatively.

The opinion does not bind the Court. According to the Court, the judges are now beginning their deliberations, and judgment will be given at a later date.

Why it matters

If the Court follows the opinion, marketing claims of 'free' for data-funded services become a consumer-law risk separate from GDPR compliance. Privacy and marketing teams should map which personal data in sign-up flows is used beyond service delivery or legal obligations, since that distinction would decide whether 'free' wording is permissible. Records of processing purposes and data lineage would become evidence for consumer-law defence, not only data protection.

Status: Non-binding opinion. Judges are beginning deliberations; judgment at a later date

Sources

  1. Advocate General Medina: A social network is not free when you pay with your data to use it (Press release No 169/26) — Court of Justice of the European UnionPrimary source

Was this useful?

Prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the editor before publication. Spotted an error? Tell us — see our editorial policy and methodology.

Governance areas

Institutions

Who should care

  • DPO
  • Legal & compliance
  • Data stewards
  • Marketing compliance leads

Related

Latest

All news

Contact the editor

Tips, corrections, questions?

Write to The Steward, the editor of Data Governance Signal. Every message is read.

editor@datagovernancesignal.com