Privacy / Regulation

EU Court of Justice confirms EDPS cannot challenge Europol transitional data provisions

The Court dismissed the EDPS appeal, finding that rules letting Europol keep processing uncategorised data did not alter the supervisor's powers or independence, so it lacked standing.

EnforcementEUNotableCourt rulingOfficial source
C-698/23 P: EDPS appeal against Europol data retention provisions dismissed as unfounded

The Court of Justice has dismissed the European Data Protection Supervisor’s appeal in Case C-698/23 P, confirming a 2023 General Court order that its action against Parliament and Council was inadmissible.

In January 2022 the EDPS ordered Europol to categorise stored personal data within six or twelve months or erase it. On 8 June 2022 Parliament and Council added transitional provisions (Articles 74a and 74b of the Europol Regulation, as amended by Regulation (EU) 2022/991) allowing continued processing of data from ongoing criminal investigations under certain conditions. The EDPS argued this retroactively legalised the practice, in effect annulled its decision and undermined its independence.

The Court held that the EDPS, although an independent supervisory authority, is not an EU institution under the Treaties, so unlike Parliament, Council or Commission it must show that the contested act is of direct and individual concern to it. As a legal person it can still bring an action, but only on the same conditions as others. The provisions did not change its rights, obligations, powers or independence guarantees, nor annul its January 2022 decision, so they did not directly affect its legal situation. The Court added that the legislative procedure behind them showed nothing that would affect the independent exercise of the EDPS’s powers. The judgment ends the case.

Why it matters

The ruling limits how far the EDPS can use the courts to defend its own supervisory decisions when the legislature later changes the underlying processing rules. Teams at EU institutions and agencies should note that an EDPS order can be overtaken by legislative change without the supervisor being able to contest it directly. It also shows that categorisation, minimisation and storage-limitation duties can be reshaped by transitional rules, so retention schedules should be checked against the current legal text, not only past regulator orders.

Status: Court ruling. Appeal dismissed; General Court's inadmissibility order upheld

Sources

  1. Press release No 165/26: Judgment in Case C-698/23 P, EDPS v Parliament and Council — Court of Justice of the European UnionPrimary source

Was this useful?

Prepared with AI assistance and reviewed by the editor before publication. Spotted an error? Tell us — see our editorial policy and methodology.

Governance areas

Institutions

Who should care

  • DPO
  • Legal & compliance
  • Records and retention managers

Related

Latest

All news

Contact the editor

Tips, corrections, questions?

Write to The Steward, the editor of Data Governance Signal. Every message is read.

editor@datagovernancesignal.com